Private or Group: Which Crime Tours Tour Should You Choose in York?
By Editorial Team · Last updated 16/08/2026
- Best season
- April to October
- How to get there
- 2 hours by train from London King's Cross
- Avg. visit duration
- 1-2 days
Considering a true crime tour of York, you’ll find four distinct offerings available, each providing a fascinating look into the city’s darker past. Generally speaking, when choosing between a shared group experience and a more bespoke private tour, there are several factors to weigh – primarily cost, flexibility, and the overall atmosphere you're hoping for. Group tours tend to offer a significantly lower price point, typically ranging from £12 to £50, allowing you to explore these chilling stories with fellow enthusiasts.
However, this affordability comes at the expense of personalized attention and pacing. Group tours operate on a fixed schedule and route, meaning everyone experiences the same information and moves at a pace dictated by the larger group. This can sometimes feel rushed or crowded, diminishing the immersive quality of the experience.
If you’re seeking a more intimate encounter with York's criminal history and are willing to invest slightly more, a private tour offers considerable advantages. The price range for these options stretches from £60 upwards, reflecting the dedicated guide and tailored itinerary. You gain complete control over the pace, questions asked, and areas explored, creating a truly bespoke experience.
The top-rated option – "The Underworld Tours: True Crime Walk of York" – currently boasts an impressive 5.0/5 rating based on six reviews and costs £14. This highlights the quality and engaging nature of these tours, regardless of group size.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your budget and desired level of interaction. For a casual exploration with others, a standard group tour provides excellent value. But if you’re prioritizing flexibility, a more detailed investigation, and a truly memorable experience, a private tour is undoubtedly the way to go – particularly considering options can range up to £105.