Private or Group: Which Rail Tours Tour Should You Choose in Edinburgh?
By Editorial Team · Last updated 16/08/2026
- Best season
- May to September
- How to get there
- 4.5 hours by train from London King's Cross, or fly into Edinburgh Airport
- Avg. visit duration
- 2-3 days
Considering a rail tour of Edinburgh, you’ll find five fantastic options available through Rail Tours, all averaging an impressive 4.7 out of 5 stars. The duration of these tours varies considerably, ranging from just 330 minutes to a full 810 minutes, so think carefully about how much time you want dedicated to your exploration.
Generally, when choosing between private and group rail tours, there are key trade-offs to consider. Group tours offer significantly lower prices – the most affordable options fall within the £19 to £259 range – allowing you to experience a memorable journey without breaking the bank. However, this comes with inherent compromises in terms of flexibility; you'll be travelling alongside other guests and moving at a pace dictated by the group’s itinerary.
Conversely, private tours represent a more tailored experience, although they come at a higher cost. You can expect to pay upwards of £200 for a truly bespoke journey that caters precisely to your interests and preferences. Private tours offer greater control over the pace, allowing you to linger longer in places you particularly enjoy, and create a more intimate atmosphere.
The most highly-rated tour currently available is the "Hogwarts Express and Scottish Highlands Tour from Edinburgh," boasting an impressive 4.8/5 rating based on 1571 reviews, and priced at £200. This suggests that focusing on destinations like the Highlands can be a rewarding investment for those seeking a higher standard of experience.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your priorities: budget versus personalized exploration. We recommend assessing how much you’re willing to spend and what kind of travel companion – large group or intimate guide – suits your style.